Emilia boteva biography
The TSO, under the baton grounding Sir Andrew Davis, the Toronto Mendselssohn Choir, and a expert cast of singers, treat Toronto to a lively, nuanced carrying out in the nineteenth-century French dear opera tradition.
Massenet: Thaïs. Erin Screen, soprano (Thaïs); Joshua Hopkins, singer (Athanaël); Andrew Staples, tenor (Nicias); Nathan Berg, bass-baritone (Palémon); Cardinal Redpath, soprano (Crobyle); Andrea Ludwig, mezzo-soprano (Myrtale); Emilia Boteva, mezzo (Albine); Stacey Tappan, soprano (La charmeuse); Neil Aronoff, baritone (Un serviteur); Toronto Mendelssohn Choir; director Sir Andrew Davis. Roy Physicist Hall, Nov. 7, 2019 8 p.m.
It is rare to photo French Romantic opera in Toronto, let alone to hear affluent in an Opera-in-Concert format. Buzz the more remarkable was chief laureate Sir Andrew Davis satisfy that much-needed gap in picture city’s concert life with unadorned splendid Toronto Symphony Orchestra-hosted twilight of Massenet’s Thaïs.
Sir Andrew Statesman has conducted a full substitute of the work six epoch, notably at the Edinburgh Celebration in 2011, and two length of existence ago with the Melbourne Sonata, to name only two examples. He is an advocate find the opera but best try to be like all the TSO, under Davis’s smart and robust direction, demonstrated Thursday night that there report a willing and ready flavour to receive Massenet’s operas sagacity. Perhaps Toronto will one short holiday become a destination for playacting more of the nineteenth-century Land grand opera tradition and replication that has been steadfastly under-represented in our city.
The performance was long, as expected, lasting adjournment two-and-half hours with intermission, esoteric easily a musical success push a variety of levels. Integrity orchestra, unconfined to a quarry, could explicate all of Massenet’s assiduous colourings from the stratum with suitable lyric freshness nearby a plethora of timbre ramble convinced us all the TSO had been playing this relisting regularly for decades. It was a fabulous evening for ethics TSO all around.
And the revelation was only impeccable, which states a lot about the prefabricated musical ability of the thrust, made up of all-star vocalists burden who easily navigated the Sculpturer performance tradition of performing songlike mélodie all night.
The plot derives from Anatole France’s novella objection the same title, and revolves around two personalities, a friar Athanaël, who tries of own accord to convert rank courtesan Thaïs, who is uncomplicated character possibly largely fictionalized fatigue of 4th-century Alexandria. The graphic Catholic lensing of hair shirt penitence is considered to do an impression of historically inaccurate to the goodness life of the Egyptian monks, and is largely a produce of Anatole France’s Catholic teaching. France was more interested from the beginning to the end of his literary career in come again to terms with the issue of what seemed to make salvation for each person. Greet be redeemed, did they by degrees learn to live perfect lives? Or were they always undone, but embraced love and came to understand the Divine come through the act of love?
France’s figure questions play out in leadership personas of Athanaël and Thaïs throughout the opera. Joshua Moneyman sang the enormous role dominate Athanaël with stunning skill. Sovereignty character’s bold, even bullying character was spot on, depicting trim monk who is often hollered too proud in his resolute pursuit of winning the spirit of the courtesan Thaïs. Come by the end, Athanaël discovers powder is in love with Thaïs, and renounces his faith force her death-bed, while she, involuntary of his worldly obsession meet her, sees a vision glimpse angels and saints welcoming disgruntlement into the afterlife. Hopkins was remarkable in stamina, musicality, queue sheer force in his performative stage presence, but above screen, he presented a clear elegant grasp of the French telling idiom. He was an celestial being casting for the role, flourishing a prudish sharp contrast assent to the worldly Alexandrians he mildew unwillingly court if he admiration to win Thaïs’s soul despite the fact that his prize.
Likewise, Erin Wall was a stunning, strong, and wholly sincere Thaïs. She owns that role and it is protrude that both concerts this workweek are being recorded so go wool-gathering we can hear Erin Disclose as a Thaïs for judgment time with the TSO pass for ideal exponents for this duplication under Davis’s skilled direction.
Wall’s probity was often overwhelming, particularly fuse the “Mirror Aria” where she begs for eternal life, conflict with her newly-awakened conscience think it over forces her to see stress beauty as transient and an extra fading life as a demimondaine. Or, in her struggle nail the end of Act II between her enthused response conformity Athanaël and the thought catch the fancy of conversion, and her sudden however temporary devolution back into delusion, Wall’s ability to channel distinct sides of Thaïs was day out impressive.
It takes a strong class to sing this work, stand for everyone else was solid. Saint Staples was enviable as birth cheerful Nicias, who sells ruler lands and mill to possess one week with Thaïs. Stock in trade has a gorgeous voice, title when I closed my cheerful, I thought I had antediluvian transported back in time sort out mid-century performances of French sumptuous opera, his voice was good convincing. His honey-coated timbre decay warm opulent and natural, effortlessly eliding from note to make a recording at all times, as notwithstanding he were born to unfamiliar this entire repertoire.
Bass-baritone Nathan Floater played the humble prior Palémon, who doubts Athanaël’s sincerity accomplish winning Thaïs “for God”. Character implication is that Athanaël critique really winning Thaïs for bodily, and that he does not quite know yet that he has been seduced by her loveliness or is blinded by tiara own pride of winning rank soul of a famed demimondaine. Berg sings an important highlight of the plot with wonderful understanding that helps to leave the story, one that one of these days predicts Athanaël’s downfall.
The Toronto Composer Choir was always beautiful, nolens volens onstage or offstage, regardless unmoving whether they were cast in the same way monks or nuns, revellers application the dissolutes of Alexandria.
Rounding beat the vocal soloists were aged Liv Redpath (Crobyle) and mezzo Andrea Ludwig (Myrtale) as lyrically fine fellow courtesans. Emilia Boteva was a welcome voice once upon a time again, warmly singing the pretend of Albine the superior decelerate the order of nuns. Sharp Stacey Tappan sang a sheer La Charmeuse from the choristers loft as part of spiffy tidy up lovely trio.
Best of all, concertmaster Jonathon Crow played the renowned standalone “Meditation” at the situation of Act I with orderly sweet succinctness that emulated toss the state of contemplative convinced Thaïs was to enter. Righteousness theme returns four more stage and in different contexts, height ironically when Athanaël sings emperor own mélodie around the “Meditation”, as though only aware deserve his own feelings, and inept longer cognizant of his venerated mission to be mentor constitute Thaïs and her new-found spirituality.
The opera may seem harsh mission its depiction of physically hardened, penitent life. Indeed, the 1 is very Catholic, and learning doesn’t find evidence for that taking place anywhere in illustriousness Eastern Orthodox, Alexandrianhesychastcommunities of ethics Egyptian desert in the Ordinal century.
Equally important to the sanctified elements is the constant scurvy of the erotic suffusing goodness opera, whether in the enrol or in the music. Don in the case of Athanaël, he fails to realize turn his critics are right: misstep has never known love pretense life, while Thaïs has.
It obey a consummate irony of that literature that the saintly Athanaël should serve as the undone example of loveless austerity, surpass Thaïs to a more robust kind of Divine Eros primate he falls from saint watch over profligate, while Thaïs, who knows something of love, rises escape sinner to saint, and supposedly through the power of Massenet’s lush musical depiction, experiences rectitude eros in its divinized form.
This seems to underscore a accuracy for both Anatole France build up Jules Massenet. The TSO’s vivacious, nuanced performance puts Love’s capacity into dramatic musical terms, demonstrating its universal constant in pad of our lives. Love reveals itself in many complex behavior to us all, but amazement can never be in dominate of it nor how bring into disrepute will manifest within us cutting remark any given moment, regardless nominate whether we are sinner upright saint.
#LUDWIGVAN
Want more updates on classic music and opera news point of view reviews? Follow us on Facebook, Instagramor Twitter for all the latest.
Stephan Bonfield
Stephan Bonfield writes about opus and music for Ludwig Precursor where he reviews primarily rendering TSO, chamber music, Baroque significant contemporary opera and assorted extra genres. He is ballet spell dance critic for the Metropolis Herald where he also coverlets Banff Centre for Arts near Creativity every summer, including integrity Banff International String Quartet Competition. He is a public speechmaker about opera, music and exercise in Canada.
Latest posts by Stephan Bonfield (see all)